Benjamin Franklin stated, “By failing to organize, you are getting ready to fail.” Sounds smart, however I doubt Benjamin Franklin carried on a busy litigation observe.
Throughout my 40-plus years within the trenches, I all the time ready my purchasers previous to examinations for discovery, additionally identified within the USA as depositions. However however my adherence to Benjamin Franklin’s credo, a few of my purchasers nonetheless dropped the ball regardless of how properly I ready them.
I might ship out a letter describing the method, and, in fact, we’d meet upfront to go over the case and ensure the purchasers understood what awaits them. Usually, after explaining the drill and admonishing the shopper to inform the reality, these directions particularly boiled right down to about 5 details.
1. Maintain your solutions quick—by no means volunteer data
Simpler stated than adopted. I had a case involving a younger lady who suffered extreme facial scarring in a motorcar automobile accident. We pleaded that because of the wreck, she turned depressed. On the discovery, the opposing counsel requested when she began taking her antidepression treatment. She replied, “About two years in the past, earlier than Christmas, simply after I broke up with my fiance.”
This reply opened up a Pandora’s field. The opposing lawyer beamed, as if he simply found Blackbeard’s treasure. He continued, “Why don’t we delve into this breakup.” His shopper investigated, interviewing the fiance, who was solely too joyful to spill some filth on my shopper, compromising our case.
Not my fault. I warned her.
2. When discussing your accidents, give an entire reply
After this catastrophe, I used to reiterate the necessity to preserve it quick, even telling purchasers about my “fiance” case. Evidently, one shopper’s pendulum swung the opposite approach. Mike was a sports activities jock who loved participating in summer time and winter sports activities, together with snowboarding, hockey, martial arts, marathon operating, tennis and pingpong, to call just some. I used to be stunned he by no means participated in an Olympics triathalon.
Sadly, he suffered accidents in a automobile accident, which hit his enjoyment of life large time. At his examination, he took my recommendation about protecting it quick—to an excessive. When requested what he can now not do, he replied, “I can’t play pingpong.”
I felt like giving him a kick below the desk. What flashed in entrance of me was that iconic James Bond scene in From Russia With Love the place Col. Klebb (the Spectre agent) prompts a poison change spike in her shoe as she struggles with Bond. However really, I felt like kicking myself. The place did I’m going mistaken? At the very least the shopper listened to me about protecting his solutions quick.
3. Don’t exaggerate your accidents
A typical query protection counsel would ask was, “On a scale of 1 to 10, how would you charge your backaches? One is gentle, and 10 is a 911 name.” Though this one received by means of to most purchasers, one shopper right here really stated emphatically, “Ten!”
Opposing counsel continued, “Do you need to take a break, so you possibly can name an ambulance?” The shopper replied, “No, I simply have to face up; I can’t sit for greater than quarter-hour straight.”
The issue at this level was that he already had been seated for over an hour.
I simply knew my case hit an iceberg. However not like the Titanic, we had no lifeboats.
4. Don’t give absolute numbers, resembling for occasions, distances, dates, and so on., until you might be sure
I might counsel they go away some wiggle room, saying “about 50 toes” or “roughly three months” or “between 10 and 15 seconds.” Though this suggestion labored more often than not, there’s a tendency for folks to not need to sound ignorant, and so they really feel they have to be particular.
I used to be as soon as the beneficiary of an opposing get together who, once I requested how briskly his truck was touring in a 30-miles-per-hour zone about 10 seconds earlier than getting into the intersection going through an amber mild, replied, “I used to be crawling, 20 miles per hour, neither extra nor much less.” And but he couldn’t cease. I went on to a different subject rapidly, not making an attempt for a house run. Sure!
5. This can be a solemn event; don’t be afraid of the opposite lawyer, however don’t get too get too pleasant, both
This was not a standard downside, but it surely as soon as took me aback.
I warned the shopper that opposing counsel chilly be a bit abrasive. To my shock, my opponent confirmed up sporting a tie lined with Looney Tunes characters. My shopper breathed a sigh of reduction. He anticipated an ogre, and he was getting Bugs Bunny.
Moreover, quite the opposite, the 2 turned a bit cordial, and so they began discussing favourite cartoon characters. The opposite lawyer simply liked the Highway Runner, whereas my shopper routed for Wile E. Coyote. They achieved on the spot rapport, agreeing that the No. 1 character was Yosemite Sam.
The ambiance all through was actually mild and jovial. The way in which the temper persevered, I believed perhaps I might go away the room, that my shopper didn’t want my companies at this stage. Fortuitously, the case resolved favorably shortly thereafter. Perhaps it helped that I additionally added my vote of approval of Yosemite Sam.
Benjamin Franklin was proper on together with his remark concerning the significance of preparation. However the perfect of us, regardless of how properly ready, will in some way nonetheless have a few of our circumstances blow up on the examination workplace, although perhaps not from a tool manufactured by Acme bombs.
Marcel Strigberger, after 40-plus years of practising civil litigation within the Toronto space, closed his regulation workplace and determined to proceed his humor writing and talking passions. His newest e book is First, Let’s Kill the Lawyer Jokes: An Attorney’s Irreverent Serious Look at the Legal Universe. Go to MarcelsHumour.com, and observe him at @MarcelsHumour on X, previously generally known as Twitter.
ABAJournal.com is accepting queries for unique, considerate, nonpromotional articles and commentary by unpaid contributors to run within the Your Voice part. Particulars and submission tips are posted at “Your Submissions, Your Voice.”