Trials & Litigation
New homicide trial ordered over juror’s psychological well being disaster in ninth Circuit
A person’s convictions for a killing on the waters off California’s coast have been vacated by the ninth U.S. Circuit Courtroom of Appeals at San Francisco on Thursday. (Picture by Jason Doiy/Getty Photos)
A person’s convictions for a killing on the waters off California’s coast have been vacated by the ninth U.S. Circuit Courtroom of Appeals at San Francisco on Thursday, declaring {that a} mistrial ought to have been known as after a juror experiencing a psychological well being disaster throughout deliberations was dismissed.
Law360 has the story.
After disagreements with fellow jurors within the 12-day trial with three days of deliberations, the juror reported that she was in a psychological well being disaster.
As a result of the dismissal was tied to her views on the deserves of the case concerning defendant Hoang Xuan Le on expenses of first-degree homicide, conspiracy and gun possession, the dismissal was allowed, ninth Circuit Decide Michelle Friedland wrote.
“The choice—allowing dismissal when a majority’s stress ultimately succeeds in incapacitating a dissenting juror—would give jurors perverse incentives and undermine the jury proper enshrined in our Structure,” Friedland wrote within the courtroom’s opinion.
Write a letter to the editor, share a story tip or update, or report an error.