It was one other thrilling morning for Stan Woodward, the omnipresent affiliate lawyer basic, who received reamed out by Decide April Perry in Chicago for being very dangerous at legislation … once more.
Woodward’s whole job consists of parachuting in to courtrooms the place the federal government is in hassle and making issues a lot worse. In Chicago, US Legal professional Andrew Boutros’s workplace was already flailing after being compelled to dismiss expenses towards the “Broadview 6” for obstruction of a authorities official within the conduct of his duties, i.e., getting hit by an ICE agent’s automotive in the course of a protest. The federal government spent months indignantly denouncing the allegations of prosecutorial misconduct as “fevered paranoia and delusional hypothesis.” However the unsealed grand jury transcripts confirmed three separate displays to the identical panel in October of 2025, every of which was stricken by apparent impropriety.
In open courtroom, USA Boutros assured Decide Perry that he solely found the issue 5 months later. And his workplace assured the courtroom that they’d had no discussions with Important Justice in regards to the case.
Seems … not a lot.
Boutros was emailed a replica of the primary grand jury transcript, with vouching on the primary web page, 5 days later. As Decide Perry noted, he would have needed to approve re-presenting the case after a no-bill, and it’s “unfathomable” that he would have finished so with out “the perfect proof accessible to him about what went mistaken within the grand jury.” And in August, the federal government conceded there had been ‘discussions’ with Important Justice about ‘case updates,’ and earlier this month the previous head of the FBI’s Chicago workplace alleged in a lawsuit that Boutros met with Ag Todd Blanche and FBI Director Kash Patel in regards to the case.
On the afternoon of October 30, 2026, simply hours earlier than a response to Decide Perry’s request for info was due, Woodward and his sidekick Enrique Carniero clocked in, and two different AUSAs clocked out. He proceeded to docket a lecture on the courtroom’s inherent powers, scolding Decide Perry that she was obligated to show any investigation of misconduct by DOJ attorneys over to the DOJ itself.
This was adopted by three weeks of wide-eyed requests for “clarification,” interspersed with sneering denunciations of the choose’s “freewheeling, quasi-inquisitorial, quasi-prosecutorial ‘inquest.’”
Final evening, hours earlier than the AUSAs had been because of hand Decide Perry in digital camera proffers of their testimony — together with no matter DOJ claims is privileged — Woodward struck again.
“The USA strikes for the referral to a particular grasp or an in any other case disinterested judicial officer to conduct preliminary rulings on privilege,” he wrote, including that “a impartial arbiter is required to rule on privilege disputes that will come up in stated inquiry.”
“The Courtroom has assumed an executive-branch operate, so except it abandons that operate, it could not additionally retain the judicial energy to rule on questions of privilege,” Woodward huffed.
As an incandescently pissed off Decide Perry identified in a minute order this morning, the federal government’s temporary performed a little bit quick and unfastened with the caselaw:
Because the Courtroom famous earlier this week — and the circumstances cited by the Authorities uniformly maintain — ruling on questions of privilege is a judicial operate. See, e.g., In re Search Warrant Issued June 13, 2019, 942 F.3d 159,176 (4th Cir. 2019) (holding that decision of privilege disputes “is a judicial operate”). Equally, it’s normal observe for judges to rule on motions concerning the admission of proof in proceedings the place the choose can also be the factfinder — together with
throughout suppression hearings and bench trials. The Seventh Circuit has famous its religion in a
choose’s potential to take action. See, e.g., Ashford v. Gilmore, 167 F.3d 1130, 1136 (seventh Cir. 1999)
(“[T]he legislation presumes that judges are usually not influenced by improper proof introduced earlier than
them.”); In re Salem, 465 F.3d 767, 777 (seventh Cir. 2006) (noting that “the place the factfinder
and the gatekeeper are the identical, the courtroom doesn’t err in admitting the proof topic to
the flexibility later to exclude it or disregard it”).
On prime of which, a particular grasp could be supervised by the choose, who would assessment any of his rulings de novo, together with any dispute over privileged discovery.
And, not for nothing, however submitting yet one more eleventh hour submitting after getting referred to as out by the choose for “gamesmanship” is a alternative.
“The Authorities has recognized for greater than 5 months that the Courtroom deliberate to carry a listening to concerning the conduct of the federal prosecutors on this matter, and for greater than three months that doubtlessly privileged communications could be at subject throughout that listening to,” Decide Perry fumed. “Regardless of this, the Authorities waited till 6:50 p.m. the evening earlier than doubtlessly privileged supplies could be tendered to the Courtroom to file its movement. The request is subsequently premature.”
However apart from that, BANG UP JOB, STAN!
So …
The AUSAs are because of hand Decide Perry their proffers right this moment. DOJ has till Tuesday to elucidate why she shouldn’t get to learn them. And everyone seems to be due again in courtroom on December 2.
Will Important Justice let its personal prosecutors take the stand? Or will it run to the Seventh Circuit, screaming about some privilege or different as a tiny figleaf to cowl its bare contempt?
US v. Rabbitt [Docket via Court Listener]
Liz Dye produces the Legislation and Chaos Substack and podcast. You’ll be able to subscribe by clicking the brand:

The put up DOJ Demand To Hide Misconduct Inside Special Master Fails To Impress Judge appeared first on Above the Law.